Top ratedFeatured pros
Top-rated in Hartville
All tire shops in Hartville
Showing 1–8 of 13
Taz Tires CantonTop rated
5.0127 reviews on Google
Serves Jackson Township
“Absolutely outstanding service! I came in needing new tires and luis and madi took care of everything quickly and professionally for me. I’ll definite…”— madison cottrell on Google
Uniontown Tire Co IncTop rated
5.0137 reviews on Google
Serves Hartville
“Top of the line place. Excellent service. Took in offset rims and oversized tires and the job they did is awesome. Perfectly balanced. Finally found a…”— J krager on Google
5.07 reviews on Google
Serves Lake Township
“I’ve worked with Roadrunner Tires for a few years now. He is honest about when I need to replace my tires, handles all the maintenance (rotation and b…”— Russell Plent on Google
Major League Tire and ServiceTop rated
4.8207 reviews on Google
Serves Hartville
“Shout out and 5 star review for Major League Tire. They consistently had excellent customer service and repair work. I recently stopped in for a slow…”— Jacqui Bianchi on Google
4.8176 reviews on Google
Serves Louisville
“The guys were great. They had a great sense of humor. They gave me a military discount. They didn’t have to do that. I just did my business. Tipped an…”— Scott Eibel on Google
Jim's Auto CareTop rated
4.7178 reviews on Google
Serves Hartville
“I dealt with Mark... And he was wonderful... He understood my situation and he was a very professional and very understanding. I work next door at the…”— Darin Upperman on Google
American Tire CenterTop rated
4.7147 reviews on Google
Serves Lake Township
“Woke up to a flat tire and wasn’t sure where to go to have it looked at. My friends come here and told me to give them a call. They were able to get m…”— Brian on Google
Yoder's Auto ServicesTop rated
4.7125 reviews on Google
Serves Louisville
“Had to stop by and give a 5 star rating after hearing my Dad rave about the service here for years. He is 91 and Yoder's has taken care of him for as…”— Michael Ferry on Google
About tire shops in Hartville
Hartville is Village in Lake Township famous for the Hartville Flea Market and Hartville Marketplace draw. Local pros service neighborhoods including downtown, near the Marketplace. The Marketplace, Hartville Kitchen, and surrounding antique shops draw regional traffic on weekends, with several wedding venues clustered in the surrounding countryside. Tell us what the car needs and we'll match you with Hartville-area shops in minutes — local owners, real customers, same-day quotes when you need them.
Common questions
How much do new tires cost in Hartville?+
Budget passenger tires run $80 to $120 each. Mid-range all-seasons are $100 to $200. Premium and performance tires run $175 to $350. Winter tires are $130 to $250. Run-flats (BMW, Lexus, some Mercedes) run $250 to $450. Mounting, balancing, valve stems, and disposal add $25 to $40 per tire on top.
When should I replace my tires?+
The legal minimum is 2/32" of tread, but Hartville weather is harder on tires than that minimum was written for. A better rule for our four-season climate: stick a quarter in the tread groove with Washington's head down — if the top of his head is visible, you're below 4/32" and it's time to shop. Anything under 6/32" is borderline for snow.
Do I need dedicated winter tires in Hartville?+
All-seasons handle most Hartville winters acceptably for front- and all-wheel-drive vehicles. Dedicated winter tires (on a second set of wheels) dramatically improve stopping and traction on ice and packed snow. Rear-wheel-drive cars almost need them. The economics work out close to even over 6 to 8 years because each set lasts longer when only used in one season.
How often should I rotate my tires?+
Every 5,000 to 8,000 miles for most cars. Rotation runs $20 to $50 at most Hartville shops and is often free if you bought the tires there. Pair it with an alignment check every 30,000 miles or when the steering wheel sits off-center. Skipping rotation can shorten tire life by 10,000 to 15,000 miles.
Can I patch a tire or do I need to replace it?+
A small puncture (under a quarter inch) on the central tread can be patched or plugged for $20 to $50 and restored to full safety. Sidewall damage is not repairable — a nail in the sidewall means a new tire. The same goes for any puncture larger than a quarter inch or damage from running flat.
How do I find tire shops in Hartville, Ohio?+
Browse tire shops on StarkPros who serve Hartville and the surrounding Stark County area. Each listing includes reviews from past customers, service details, and a direct quote request form — so you can compare options before reaching out.